Teachers have never had more instructional strategies at their disposal. A quick search can produce dozens of ways to introduce a concept, engage students in discussion, organize cooperative learning, check for understanding, or review material. Educator “influencers” plug a plethora of activities, techniques, and resources.

All of these can be useful. But just having more tools does not make us better builders.

There is an important difference between planning instruction and designing instruction. Planning often begins with questions such as: What will I teach? What activities will my students do? What resources will I use?

Instructional design asks a more fundamental question: What thinking must my students do in order to learn this, and how can I design instruction that intentionally engages that thinking?

This distinction matters because students do not learn simply because we teach. Nor do they necessarily learn because they are busy, engaged, or enjoying an activity. Learning requires mental processing.

Research in the learning sciences continues to reinforce this point. Relevant prior knowledge provides a foundation for making sense of new information, and intentionally activating that knowledge can facilitate learning. Recent neuroscience research also points to the importance of students actively working with new knowledge—exploring, applying, retrieving, evaluating, and manipulating it—rather than merely receiving information. These findings echo a principle that has long been central to the Architecture of Learning: teaching processes should be based on learning processes.

Think of an architect. An architect does not select attractive windows, an interesting staircase, and a collection of favorite building materials and then attempt to assemble them into a house. The architect begins with the structure—with an understanding of how the parts must work together to accomplish the intended purpose.

Teachers need the same kind of thinking.

A compelling activity may be excellent instruction—or it may simply be a compelling activity. A powerful questioning strategy may deepen learning—or it may be used at a point when students lack the knowledge necessary to benefit from it. Even a research-supported instructional practice gains its power from when, why, and how it is used.

That is the premise behind the Architecture of Learning. The quality of our instructional design influences the quality of the learning our instruction produces. Like a blueprint for a building, a sound instructional design provides structure and coherence to the individual choices we make as teachers.

Good teaching doesn’t happen by accident.

It is designed.

* * *

Research supporting this article

Dubinsky, J. M., & Hamid, A. A. (2024). The neuroscience of active learning and direct instruction. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 163, 105737.

Hattan, C., Alexander, P. A., & Lupo, S. M. (2024). Leveraging what students know to make sense of texts: What the research says about prior knowledge activation. Review of Educational Research, 94(1), 73–111.  Article/record

Fiorella, L. (2023). Making sense of generative learning. Educational Psychology Review, 35, 50.